Particle Fever -- Film Review
Particle Fever
Directed
by Mark Levinson
This is a documentation of science as a media circus. It is a public relations infomercial for
CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research that operates the Large
Hadron Collider near Geneva, Switzerland.
I was disappointed in it to the point of loathing. I was expecting something akin to the old
NOVA programs on PBS, where they seriously examine the scientific issues and
provide in depth biographical portraits of the scientists involved. It wasn't anything like that at all. This was superficial and childish. It was a cross between the Oscars and a cheerleading
section at a basketball game. But this
is a game that no one understands or knows how to play. So it is hard to understand why anyone is
cheering or what they are cheering for.
They
showed a graphic with an H in the center of it and told us that's the Higgs
Boson; that's what we're looking for.
It's the key to the universe.
It's the long sought Holy Grail of particle physics. Well, . . . OK. But no attempt was made to explain what it is and why it is so
important, or why you need this gargantuan apparatus to find it. Maybe they decided that we are all just too
dumb to get it, so they would try to create some phony drama that would hop us
up and entertain us. But it didn't work
on me. I have too much curiosity --
which was the main justification they gave for building this behemoth in the
first place. The film should have
pandered to that curiosity that is driving the scientists. The scientific issues should be engaging and
interesting enough in their own right to hold the interest of the
audience. But the filmmakers simply
didn't believe in it. They opted to make
something like late night television.
I'm getting more annoyed the more I think about it.
A hundred years ago a lone, eccentric scientist, driven by
little more than his own peculiar interests, could build an apparatus in his
basement that was capable of making important discoveries. That is no longer the case. It costs a lot of money to build and operate a
mother bear like the Large Hadron Collider, and for that they need a lot of support
from political leaders and the public, since it admittedly does not produce
anything of immediate economic value.
Perhaps the debacle in the United States of the Superconducting Super
Collider struck fear in their hearts, when the U.S. Congress, in 1993, canceled
the project to build the world's largest and most energetic particle
accelerator after it was well under way.
Perhaps the thinking is that the way to garner public support is through
propaganda, public relations gimmicks, and advertising, rather than trying to
educate people about the subtleties of particle physics and the deep structure
of the universe. I disagree, but I am
certainly no expert on public relations.
My opinion is that this attitude is mistaken and this film is misguided
in its fundamental approach to the subject.
It is an unfortunate missed opportunity both to educate the public about
recent developments in particle physics and to broaden the base of public
support for large scale scientific enterprises of the type done in the Large
Hadron Collider. I don't think this film
is going to be popular, and I don't think is serves the scientists well who
participated in it and who care about pushing back the frontiers of human
knowledge and understanding the origins and structure of the universe. Even if you are suckered by the light
entertainment this film offers, you won't know very much more about the Higgs
boson when you leave than you did when you went in.